Should I Match or Contrast My Kitchen Island During a Remodel?

An island is always a great addition to any kitchen. It’s a centerpiece that draws attention whenever you walk into the space. With the correct design, a kitchen island can be the functional heart of the space.

To create the best kitchen island design, consider the best way to match your kitchen island to the rest of the kitchen. While consistency has its advantages, contrasting is also an exciting remodeling option. 

Read on to see how to achieve the best results with color designs and more.

Factors to consider when designing your kitchen island

Before setting up your kitchen island, you need to consider the following:

• Size and orientation

Ask these two questions:

• Is your kitchen big enough?
• How is your kitchen oriented?

The most common matching choice is to line up your island facing the cabinetry. This creates a consistent, minimalist aesthetic. The size of the kitchen matters, too, as a larger space will be best complemented by a large island.

• Preferred style and theme

A matching island and countertops can enhance the sleek and consistent look if you have a modern and minimalist kitchen. On the other hand, if your kitchen has a more traditional or classic feel, mixing colors and materials might be best.

• Paint and cabinetry

Your choice of paint and cabinetry is one of the considerations in matching or not matching your kitchen island to your countertops.

Multi-colored cabinets go well with a matching kitchen island design. On the other hand, you can integrate a bold island design with cabinetry uniformly painted. 

Kitchen island design: ideas for contrasting and matching

If you want to achieve a consistent and cohesive feel, you can try these:

• Make an impact with mirrored surfaces
• Bring in shining surfaces
• Borrow ideas from the color of surrounding surfaces

For a more exciting look:

• Create contrast with white
• Overhang pendant lights
• Play with complementing color combinations

Should my kitchen island contrast or match my cabinets and countertops?

There’s no straightforward answer to this. Modern kitchens are more versatile than before. Mixing elements brings excitement to the functionality and gives your kitchen island a versatile feel, which may be too bold for some individuals. A cohesive look remains one of the most favored options, but minimalism isn’t always the best. 

In the end, it comes down to personal preference. Either way, you can learn more about which option to choose by working with a design company.

Should I DIY my kitchen island remodel or hire a pro?

Building your kitchen island yourself may seem like a way to save money, but the job is better left to the professionals. You will likely make costly mistakes, making your kitchen island look unappealing and lacking functionality. 

On the other hand, a professional kitchen remodeler brings experience, expertise, and access to high-quality materials to make your kitchen island beautiful and functional. With their expertise, they can guide you in deciding whether to match or contrast your kitchen island.

Ready to transform your kitchen into a stunning and functional space?

At Stirling, we understand that every kitchen remodel is a unique project. Our team is dedicated to helping you make the right choices for your kitchen remodel, whether matching or contrasting your kitchen island. 

If you are ready to transform your kitchen in the Lehigh Valley, contact us today for a FREE estimate.